Skip to content
Shopping cart
Check out
Your cart is empty
Start shopping
  • Facebook
  • Instagram

Family Owned — Est. 1840 — Indianapolis

Everyday Luxury to Last a Lifetime

Complimentary Shipping $500+

Account
Search
Charles Mayer
Account Search HeritageWedding Registry Cart
  • Gift Guide Toggle menu
    • Shop All Gifts
    • Gifts for Her
    • Gifts for Him
    • Bridal Favorites
    • The Monogram Shop
    • Mahjong & Games
    • Hostess Gifts
    • Hostess Gifts Under $50
    • Paper & Stationery
    • Charles Mayer Gift Card
  • Home Decor Toggle menu
    • Shop by Category Toggle menu
      • Shop All Home Decor
      • Art & Prints
      • Lighting
      • Vases & Florals
      • Candleholders & Hurricanes
      • Trays, Boxes & Catchalls
      • Decorative Objects
      • Coffee Table Books
    • Shop by Brand Toggle menu
      • Abigails
      • AERIN
      • Assouline
      • Botanical Collections
      • Chic Fire
      • Hunt Slonem
      • Les Ceramiques de Lussan
      • Lucky Fish Gallery
      • Maison Maison
      • Michael Aram
      • MOVA Globes
      • Slim Aarons
      • Soicher Marin
      • Stephen Wilson Studio
      • Throwbridge Gallery
      • Zafferano
      • Nicolette Mayer
      • Caspari
  • Tableware Collections Toggle menu
    • Shop by Category Toggle menu
      • Shop All Tableware
      • Wine Glasses
      • Champagne & Cocktail
      • Tumblers & Highballs
      • Decanters & Carafes
      • Bar Tools & Accessories
    • Casual China Toggle menu
      • Arte Italica
      • Gien
      • Juliska
      • Nashi Home
      • Simon Pearce
      • Skyros Designs
      • Vietri
    • Fine China Toggle menu
      • Anna Weatherley
      • Bernardaud
      • Ginori 1735
      • Halcyon Days
      • Herend
      • L'Objet
      • Meissen
      • Mottahedeh
      • Pickard
      • Raynaud
      • Robert Haviland
      • Royal Crown Derby
    • Crystal & Glassware Toggle menu
      • Baccarat
      • Lalique
      • Moser Crystal
      • Saint-Louis
      • Varga Crystal
      • William Yeoward Crystal
      • Mario Luca Giusti
      • Mariposa
      • Simon Pearce
      • Sophie Lou Jacobsen
      • Vietri
      • Zafferano
    • Flatware & Serveware Toggle menu
      • Christofle Silver
      • Claude Dozorme
      • Couzon
      • Ercuis
      • Juliska
      • Laguiole en Aubrac
      • MATCH Pewter
      • Sabre
      • Vietri
      • Andrew Pearce
      • Beatriz Ball
      • Jan Barboglio
      • Salisbury
  • Frames Toggle menu
    • Shop by Material Toggle menu
      • Shop All Frames
      • Sterling & Silver
      • Gold & Brass
      • Enamel & Lacquer
      • Beaded & Mother of Pearl
      • Leather
      • Wood & Burl
      • Acrylic & Lucite
      • Wedding, Baby & Engravable
    • Shop by Size & Price Toggle menu
      • 4x6
      • 5x7
      • 8x10 & Larger
      • Under $100
      • $100 to $250
      • $250 & Up
    • Shop by Brand Toggle menu
      • Addison Ross
      • Christofle
      • L'Objet
      • Mariposa
      • Michael Aram
      • Monica Rich Kosann
      • Pigeon & Poodle
      • Reed & Barton
      • Tara Wilson
      • Tizo Design
  • Candles & Fragrance Toggle menu
    • Shop by Category Toggle menu
      • Shop All Candles & Fragrance
      • Holiday Candles
      • Scented Candles
      • Statement Candles
      • Votives & Minis
      • Tapers & Pillars
      • Diffusers & Room Sprays
      • Gifts Under $50
      • Candleholders & Hurricanes
    • Shop by Brand Toggle menu
      • Antica Farmacista
      • LAFCO
      • Little Bee of CT
      • Nest Fragrances
      • Ortigia
      • Rigaud Paris
      • Saint Candles
      • Simon Pearce Candles
      • Trudon
      • Voyage et Cie
  • Linen Toggle menu
    • Shop by Category Toggle menu
      • Shop All Linen
      • Holiday Linens
      • Tablecloths
      • Table Runners
      • Placemats
      • Dinner & Cocktail Napkins
      • Tea, Kitchen & Guest Towels
      • Napkin Rings & Place Cards
      • Hostess Gifts Under $50
    • Shop by Brand Toggle menu
      • Bodrum
      • Busatti
      • Deborah Rhodes
      • Garnier Thiebaut
      • Julian Mejia
      • Juliska
      • Kim Seybert
      • Vietri
      • WH Hostess
  • Jewelry Toggle menu
    • Shop by Category Toggle menu
      • Shop All Jewelry
      • Necklaces
      • Earrings
      • Bracelets & Bangles
      • Rings
      • Charms, Lockets & Brooches
    • Fine Jewelry Toggle menu
      • Clara Williams
      • Lena Skadegard
      • Monica Rich Kosann
      • Mazza
    • Everyday Jewelry Toggle menu
      • Anabel Aram
      • Bittersweet Designs
      • Capucine de Wulf
      • Catherine Canino
      • Halcyon Days
      • Julie Vos
      • Kenneth Jay Lane
      • Lily Juliet
      • Lisi Lerch
  • Fashion Toggle menu
    • Shop by Category Toggle menu
      • Shop All Fashion
      • Scarves, Wraps & Hats
      • Handbags, Clutches & Pouches
      • Readers & Sunglasses
      • Apparel & Loungewear
    • Shop by Brand Toggle menu
      • Inoui et Compagnie
      • Look Optic
      • Mitchie’s Matchings
      • Sarah Stewart
      • Silk Story
      • Tiana NY
      • TRVL
      • White + Warren
  • Baby Toggle menu
    • Shop by Category Toggle menu
      • Shop All Baby
      • Blankets & Swaddles
      • Clothing
      • Plush & Toys
      • Nursery & Keepsakes
      • Gifts Under $50
    • Shop by Brand Toggle menu
      • A Soft Idea
      • Bei Bei
      • Bella Tunno
      • Elegant Baby
      • Jacaranda Living
      • Jellycat
      • Lenora
      • Little Giraffe
      • MiniMoi
      • Nella Pima
      • Susanne Lively Designs
      • Timo & Violet
  • Holiday Toggle menu
    • Shop by Category Toggle menu
      • Shop All Holiday
      • Ornaments
      • Trees & Tabletop
      • Santas, Nutcrackers & Figures
      • Wreaths, Garland & Lights
      • Stockings & Tree Trim
      • All Holiday Décor
      • The Holiday Table
      • Holiday Candles
      • Holiday Linens
      • Stocking Stuffers
      • Hanukkah
    • Shop by Brand Toggle menu
      • Anders Ruff Design Co.
      • Bauble Stockings
      • Blair's Oyster Shells
      • Caroline Hill
      • Cody Foster
      • Fig and Dove
      • Holiday Bright Lights
      • JingleNog
      • John Mark
      • Karen Didion
      • Nest Fragrances
      • Simon Pearce Trees
      • Thomas Glenn
      • Wilhelm Schweizer
  • Our Story
  • Wedding Registry
  • SALE

Match

Filter Right
136 products
Sort by
Most relevantBest sellingAlphabetically, A-ZAlphabetically, Z-APrice, low to highPrice, high to lowDate, old to newDate, new to old
Filter
Sort by
Down
Match Pewter Gabriella Large Butter Spreader
Left Right Quick View
Match Pewter Gabriella Large Butter Spreader
$90.00
Match Pewter Gabriella 3Pc. Cheese Knife Set - Charles Mayer
Quick View
Match Pewter Gabriella 3Pc. Cheese Knife Set
$364.00
Match Pewter Ice Scoop - Charles Mayer
Quick View
Match Pewter Ice Scoop
$179.00
Match Pewter Olivia Bread Knife - Charles Mayer
Quick View
Match Pewter Olivia Bread Knife
$174.00
Match Caterina White Wine
$106.00
Match Small Pitcher - Charles Mayer
Quick View
Match Small Pitcher
$405.00
Match Pewter Antique Straining Spoon - Charles Mayer
Quick View
Match Pewter Antique Straining Spoon
$161.00
Match Pewter Antique Slotted Spoon - Charles Mayer
Quick View
Match Pewter Antique Slotted Spoon
$161.00
Match Pewter Olivia 5Pc. Place Setting - Charles Mayer
Quick View
Match Pewter Olivia 5Pc. Place Setting
$443.00
Match Pewter Wine Carafe, Litre
Left Right Quick View
Match Pewter Wine Carafe, Litre
$168.00
Match Piccolo Low Hurricane
$155.00
Match Pewter Parmesan Dish With Spoon - Charles Mayer
Quick View
Match Pewter Parmesan Dish With Spoon
$295.00
Match  Pewter Large Crown Spoon
Left Right Quick View
Match Pewter Large Crown Spoon
$53.00
Match Pewter Covered Butter Dish
Left Right Quick View
Match Pewter Covered Butter Dish
$313.00
Match Pewter Classic Balloon Wine Glass - Charles Mayer
Quick View
Match Pewter Classic Balloon Wine Glass
$128.00
Match Pewter Classic Red Wine Glass - Charles Mayer
Quick View
Match Pewter Classic Red Wine Glass
$117.00
« Previous · 1 … 4 5 6
Charles Mayer & Co.

5629 N. Illinois St.

Indianapolis IN 46208

317-257-2900

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
Quick links
  • Gift Guide
  • Tableware
  • Holiday
  • Baccarat
  • Search
  • Gift Registry
  • Our Story
  • Events
  • Return Policy
Newsletter

Sign up for exclusive offers, original stories, events and more.

© 2026 Charles Mayer. Powered by Shopify
Adding to your registry My registry

Added to your registry

Search for something else Back to my registry